Angry about sex-worker article
I'm writing to express my disappointment with the Jan. 16 feature, "One man's battle against Midtown prostitutes and their johns," by Andisheh Nouraee.
There are two separate matters here. The first, and most obvious, is that Gower and Denby are dangerous vigilantes. I am glad that their deplorable tactics are being exposed.
It should go without saying that posting videos of sex workers on YouTube is a horrible idea. What is the goal? Sex workers, especially street prostitutes, are disproportionately the targets of violent crime. Violent criminals target sex workers because they know they can get away with it. (In fact, this was the exact justification given by Gary Ridgway, who was convicted of the murders of over 40 prostitutes.) Gower's dehumanization of sex workers through his behavior and language perpetuates the cultural mores that make such violence acceptable.
But I am also disappointed with Nouraee's treatment of the issue. Nouraee learned about Gower's harassment of street workers at an event I helped organize at Charis Books, commemorating the fifth annual International Day to End Violence Against Sex Workers. After the program, he spoke with the other two organizers and me and expressed interest in learning more and possibly doing a story.
Nouraee sat through our program that night and listened as people recounted individual encounters with Gower, citing Gower's blatant homophobia and transphobia. He listened as we discussed the glaring absence of sex workers' voices in the media, as well as the fact that when sex workers are mentioned in the media, they are either troublemakers or victims – in other words, they're not people; they're useful objects in making a point and reinforcing a stereotype.
He spoke with several sex workers that night and a few weeks later, while doing research for this story. He expressed concern about making sure to include sex workers' voices.
If Nouraee tried to speak with street prostitutes in Midtown and they did not want to speak to him, he could have mentioned it in the article. Reporters do this all the time ("so-and-so declined to comment"). If that were the case, he could also reflect on why sex workers might be wary of talking to a reporter. Could it be because they're tired of having their words (and existence) twisted to fit whatever agenda is at hand?
Nouraee fails as an investigative reporter with this piece, especially as one for a paper that claims to be alternative. Terms like "transvestitute" and "real female" go unchallenged and uncorrected. Nouraee does not probe Gower about why Gower is so fixated on harassing prostitutes. He does not examine how the criminalization of prostitution perpetuates the violence that many people associate with street prostitution. He does not discuss the societal and economic conditions that lead to many transpeople working on the streets.
For people who are interested in learning more about sex workers' rights activism, some good sources of information are SWOP-USA, Desiree Alliance, COYOTE and $pread magazine.
– Amber Rhea, Decatur
Editor Ken Edelstein responds: While some at the meeting to which Amber Rhea refers complained about Gower's practices, Andisheh Nouraee didn't hear anyone there describe their "individual encounters with Gower" nor did he meet anyone there who claimed to have had direct experience with Gower. Organizers also asked Nouraee not to expose names and identities of those attending the meeting.
Later, Nouraee tracked down a woman who was involved directly in an incident with Gower, and he quoted that woman, Cheryl Courtney-Evans, extensively in the article. The article also contained quotes from transgender activists Arianna Sykes and Tracee McDaniel, who criticized the Midtown Ponce Security Association.
Another point worth considering: Gower, whom Rhea describes as homophobic, is openly gay.
Thanks, CL for covering our current budget challenges. Hooray to CL, Shook and Muller for openly discussing this issue. As the article pointed out the COO and CFO have informed me and the Council about the current challenges. With 2 years left in my term I expect to have ample time to address these problems and the strengthen the city's financial position just as we have tackled other tough problems like crumbling sewer, antiquated water system, numerous departmental overhauls, crime and the fifth runway delay. Serving as Mayor or as a Councilmember isn't for the fainthearted or thin skinned. Working hard and smart we'll tackle the budget challenges successfully.
– shirley franklin
U.S. Rep. Doug Collins, R-Gainesville, yesterday took part in an hearing held by the U.S…
"Each charge of possessing a firearm while a felon carries a maximum sentence of 10…
kasim reed, rising national democratic star, is so fetch.
Kasim Reed@KasimReed21h Please remember to vote today. I just did. The polls don't close until…