Pin It

Tucker on my mind 

Matthews offers a lesson in Southern charm

Standing in line at Matthews Cafeteria, you forget all that talk you've heard about the New South. My jaw dropped when I heard a woman strike up a conversation with two strangers about familial connections and vacation Bible school at the local Baptist church, all with a sweet Southern drawl.

The to-be-seen scene of Matthews is a cultural mish-mash of races, accents and heritage, all waiting in line for a heap of traditional Southern fare. Call it a greasy spoon, a feeding line or a meat-and-three, Matthews Cafeteria is the real thing. On any day of the week, you'll see Tucker locals crowd together within its white cinderblock walls. Sit at the red-checked oilcloth-covered tables or opt for to-go boxes to enjoy the goods at home with the family.

What we ate: A different selection of vittles is served up every weekday. Many folks insist that Thursday -- turkey day -- is the time to be there. And we mean real turkey, sliced from the bird and served with dressing ($2.90). The fried pork chops ($2.85) run a close second, along with the sausages and kraut, mushroom steak, and liver and onions. Juicy, salty fried chicken appears daily for either lunch or dinner ($2.30). Tuesday isn't too shabby, with salmon croquettes, meatloaf, chicken and dumplings, pot roast or corned beef. The meatloaf ($2.80) is served thick, and covered in a zippy, ketchupy sauce.

The sides ($1.09) also change daily, but you can usually be assured of turnip greens and creamy mashed potatoes. My broccoli casserole was a little dry, but the sweet potato souffle was oh-so-good. And while I couldn't pass up a helping of creamed corn, I let someone else enjoy the boiled okra. No thankya.

Service: The line moves rapidly thanks to the mix of self-serve sections and smiling women dishing out helpings. If you want your meal to go, you'll be treated to service as sweet as the iced tea.

Cheapest item: Cold sides include sliced tomatoes (90 cents) or deviled eggs (90 cents). You'll think you're at a summer picnic.

And for dessert: Sweet stuff like banana pudding ($1.20-$2.30), and slices of apple, pecan or blueberry pie ($1.40) fill the bill. My slice of lemon icebox pie was wonderful, and tempting enough that I nearly went back for another.

Grease count: A local told me a story of how he was coming to Matthews twice a week for takeout. When he returned after a long absence, the servers asked where he'd been. "After getting my cholesterol checked, the doctor said I had to cut it out for a while." The server assured him, with a concerned smile: "We're doing better."

  • Pin It


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Latest in Cheap Eats

More by Jerry Portwood


Search Events

  • Craft Beer Buzzkill 11

    Georgia’s antiquated distribution laws are hampering small businesses and sending national brands elsewhere. Why is Georgia refusing thousands of jobs and millions of dollars from this homegrown industry?
  • Restaurant review: The Pig and the Pearl 3

    Is Todd Richards’ new meat and seafood joint the local, neighborhood restaurant Atlantic Station’s been waiting for?
  • Restaurant Review: Gunshow 16

    A fun but uneven experience at Kevin Gillespie’s lauded eatery

Recent Comments

© 2015 Creative Loafing Atlanta
Powered by Foundation