'Trouble Boys' delves into the Replacements legacy of debauchery
Bob Mehr probes into the numerous episodes of the Replacements depraved hilarity with an ambitious and exhaustively researched new biography.
In that context, the beguiling and combustible rock ’n’ roll that the Replacements delivered – the joyous, defiant anthems and aching ballads found on records like Let It Be, Tim, and Pleased to Meet Me – were something to bond over, and feel protective about. It helped that the group’s chief songwriter and singer, Paul Westerberg, was obviously every bit as frustrated, disaffected, and recklessly romantic as we often were. They were funny, too. In addition to being the greatest band of their era, to their admirers, the Replacements were also the most relatable.
Consistency was not their strong suit. As Bob Mehr suggests in Trouble Boys: The True Story of the Replacements (Da Capo), which is the first proper biography of the group, some of their unruly behavior may have stemmed from their childhoods. Rooted in working-class in Minneapolis, none of the four original members had particularly rosy upbringings, and one of the book’s ghastly revelations is that Bob Stinson, the bands marvelous first guitarist, suffered sexual abuse from his stepfather. (The Replacements fired Bob in 1986, after which his many addictions only seemed to worsen. In 1995, he died from organ failure.)
It is also true, however, that the Replacements actively cultivated their reputations for bratty insouciance. “Westerberg would say, as a cockeyed boast … that there wasn’t a drivers license or a high school diploma among them,” Mehr writes. Wracked by self-doubt and substance abuse, they often seemed incapable of letting themselves catch a break. The group finally had a chance of earning greater mainstream success in the summer of 1989, when they landed a coveted spot opening for Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers, but they botched that opportunity as well, performing lackadaisically nearly every night. When the tour reached Nashville, Paul announced from the stage, “Tom Petty says if we fuck up one more time we’re fired. Well, fuck you Tom Petty, and fuck you Nashville.”
It’s probably not a coincidence that the sense of failure and fear of the future that beset the Replacements are also hallmarks of the alcoholic personality. The numerous episodes of debauched hilarity that Mehr recounts in Trouble Boys make for entertaining reading, but I wish he’d probed more deeply into the more subtle ways that alcoholism may have impacted the band, and into Paul’s effort to get sober, which is rather hastily narrated toward the end of the book. (Or perhaps I’m too close to that aspect of the story?) Don’t let that deter you, however. Trouble Boys is a fast-paced and energetically researched book, and for most Replacements fans, it will be as irresistible as catnip.
John McMillian is an assistant professor of history at Georgia State University and the author, most recently, of Beatles Vs. Stones.