When it comes to the future of public transit in Atlanta, theres good news and theres bad news.
The good news: After decades of bowing at the throne of roadbuilders, the Georgia Department of Transportation says its finally taking off the kneepads and getting serious about train service that would connect Atlanta to other cities in the Southeast.
The bad news: Thanks to an unexpected tiff between GDOT and city of Atlanta officials, the Beltline the transformative 22-mile loop of parks, trails and transit that would one day circle the city might be in jeopardy. Thats because the train service that GDOT is suddenly embracing would have to run on or near the proposed Beltline tracks. Whats more, Piedmont Park, the citys most iconic greenspace, might have to be severed by a heavy-rail route in order to accommodate GDOTs vision.
Last week, CL first reported that GDOT working in tandem with Amtrak threw a wrench in Beltline officials plans for light-rail, trails and additional green space near Piedmont Park. Just as Norfolk Southern, the current owner of the tracks in question, was about to surrender them to the city, GDOT and Amtrak stepped in and halted the proceedings. Those two agencies now say the tracks in dispute are vital to their own vision for commuter rail.
Simply put, because of GDOT's boorish behavior and AMTRAK's willingness to play along, the future of the city of Atlanta is at stake, Mayor Shirley Franklin wrote in an urgent letter to U.S. Congressman John Lewis to seek his assistance.
GDOTs explanation: Those rusty rail lines must be preserved for an important purpose, one which the department says has been planned since 1992. If Atlanta ever wants to see commuter rail inside city limits and a downtown terminal akin to Washington D.C.s Union Station, the trains must operate along the Decatur Belt that flanks Piedmont Park, GDOT claims.
Officials from Atlanta Beltline Inc. and the city say they were blindsided by the move. GDOT had been actively involved in numerous regional transportation plans, all of which included the Beltline in their lists of supported projects. So why potentially derail the Beltline vision and involve Amtrak, which has the power to condemn the property now? Why not step in earlier, before the city began securing funds for the Beltline and buying up land along its proposed route?
Thats a question GDOT hasnt been able to answer. Weirdly, internal GDOT documents state that the department and the city have been communicating for quite some time with no mention of a commuter rail line infringing on the wildly popular Beltline.
But one need only look at the transit-friendly policies espoused by President Barack Obama to surmise that GDOT smells federal funding and doesnt want to miss a single penny thats dropped.
Weve heard clearly from the Obama administration that high-speed rail is going to be something that is on their plates, GDOT Commissioner Gena Evans says. And were trying to think of ways to show that GDOT is committed to other modes of transportation. Im ready to do something with commuter rail.
Evans also says her department, which is in support of the Beltline, hardly kept Atlanta officials in the dark about GDOTs own commuter rail aspirations.
The citys known about it. Weve known about it. Its not like someone didnt know this was an issue, Evans says, adding that the propertys previous owner, Wayne Mason, had contacted GDOT about any possible commuter rail plans.
If heavy-rail trains dont run along the tracks, Evans says, they wont run anywhere in Atlanta. Nor would it be feasible to build high-speed rail or a downtown transit terminal thats been planned for more than a decade. Plans for the terminal which already has been earmarked for federal funds are sitting on a shelf collecting dust.
Last week, on the day the proverbial shit hit the fan, Evans told board members in a memo that the two projects could run side-by-side.
But Beltline officials say GDOTs plans wouldnt mesh with the vision of parks, bike trails, mixed-use residential developments and pedestrian thoroughfares. A large, loud, lumbering commuter rail line would be an unwelcome intrusion in that smart-growth utopia.
Many nearby residents arent too keen about GDOTs proposed remedy to run both projects side-by-side. The most controversial aspect of that proposal would be a miles-long, eight-foot-tall barrier that would block nearby residents access to Piedmont Park.
We do need high-speed rail and Georgia needs commuter rail, says Lee Biola, president of grassroots advocacy group Citizens for Progressive Transit. But Atlanta needs the Beltline. We can have all three. We just cant have all three on these tracks.
Beltline advocates, including Ryan Gravel, who conceived the project while working on his thesis at Georgia Tech, say there is an alternative to the state and Amtraks plan, which as of now, has no funding and would take years to carry out. In 2005, Gravel surveyed the various rail segments that would comprise the Beltlines spine. He concluded that Amtraks proposed commuter rail could instead run along active tracks on the west side of the city and operate out of the transit agencys current Brookwood station in south Buckhead or even a new hub in Armour Yard near Ansley Park.
But Evans, who acknowledged Gravels study in last weeks memo to board members, claims no other scenario will work. Its Decatur Belt or bust, GDOT says.
The impasse could work against Georgia a state notorious for infighting among its transportation agencies when it comes to the federal governments generosity with infrastructure funding. Terri Montague, who as CEO of Atlanta Beltline Inc. oversees the projects planning and implementation, says new U.S. Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood already has been made aware of the dispute.
Anybody looking for money for Georgia from the federal level is probably going to have to wait until theres some sense of resolution here, Montague says. Our credibility as a state has been called into question. The discord is not looked upon favorably by the federal agencies.
On Saturday, nearly 300 Beltline supporters rallied on the overgrown and rusty rails in question. They hollered chants, waved signs, and vowed to fight GDOT and Amtraks plans. Considering that some supporters in attendance also successfully thwarted GDOTs plan in the 1980s for a controversial interstate near Candler Park, its fair to say the battle could get ugly.
As CL went to press, all transit agencies involved in the brouhaha were scheduled to meet on Feb. 4. Evans says the GDOT board also will convene this month to discuss the matter.
Time is of the essence, Beltline officials say. Requests for federal funding are due throughout February. If those deadlines are missed, the project thats been touted as the most progressive in Atlantas recent history could face its most daunting challenge yet.
(Photo by Alan Friedman)
@ MBlau ""They" would push for future referenda once this one is complete. (Every 4-5…
Cassie - the folks who at the start of the Beltline pipe dream were most…
I do not think soccer in Atlanta will be a giant success but I do…
@Burroughston Broch: "They" would push for future referenda once this one is complete. (Every 4-5…
"Weyandt told residents that City Hall wouldn’t simply tackle the worst problems first and work…
Also, these people have to leave their entire country or risk death or prison due…