Friday, January 27, 2012
Politics Newt-bashing not limited to liberals
Posted by Scott Henry @ScottTheHenry on Fri, Jan 27, 2012 at 5:29 PM
- Joeff Davis
- Moi, an ass-munch?
This is the situation in which one Newton Gingrich finds himself. The irony is that it's not just liberals who find repugnant the idea of him as president, it's also Republicans who worked with him back in the day or those who simply have reasonably long memories. We already know that columnist George Will thinks Gingrich "would have made a marvelous Marxist." And that former GOP Congressman Joe Scarborough has been vocal in his belief that Newt is a "bad person" and "a danger to America."
Now comes Elliott Abrams, a former assistant secretary of state under Ronald Reagan, who seems to remind folks of the terrible things Gingrich once said as a young congressman about the GOP icon whose mantle he claims to be upholding. Abrams spins his tale in National Review Online, where conservatives are likely to see it:
Gingrich scorned Reagan’s speeches, which moved a party and then a nation, because “the president of the United States cannot discipline himself to use the correct language.” In Afghanistan, Reagan’s policy was marked by “impotence [and] incompetence.” Thus Gingrich concluded as he surveyed five years of Reagan in power that “we have been losing the struggle with the Soviet empire.” Reagan did not know what he was doing, and “it is precisely at the vision and strategy levels that the Soviet empire today is superior to the free world.”There are two things to be said about these remarks. The first is that as a visionary, Gingrich does not have a very impressive record. The Soviet Union was beginning to collapse, just as Reagan had believed it must. The expansion of its empire had been thwarted. The policies Gingrich thought so weak and indeed “pathetic” worked, and Ronald Reagan turned out to be a far better student of history and politics than Gingrich.
The second point to make is that Gingrich made these assaults on the Reagan administration just as Democratic attacks were heating up unmercifully. Far from becoming a reliable voice for Reagan policy and the struggle against the Soviets, Gingrich took on Reagan and his administration.
In other words, the Gingrich of then is much like the Gingrich of today: a dismissive know-it-all eager to explain how his understanding of domestic policy and international affairs is superior to his contemporaries — especially those he doesn't consider his intellectual equals. That might be effective in a debate against political rivals, but it's a practice that obviously burned some bridges for him along the way. Wonder who'll be next to trash the Newtster?
Comments (5)
Showing 1-5 of 5
like
dislike
You realize most of these folks are just allies of the Republican Establishment that backing Newt. Its all kind of interesting and perhaps telling because it seems to me the discourse between Hilliary Clinton and Obama was a lot more civil.
Don't get me wrong I agree with the criticism, just as I agree with the criticism of Romney. Though in many ways I'm the notion of a bridge burner is kind of appealing to me. At least I know Newt's angle and that he thinks for himself, Mitt on the other hand might as well be a cyborg programmed by some corporate focus groups.
"The problem with having been in the public forum a few decades is that there's a long record of potentially stupid or offensive stuff you've said over the years. That goes double if you happen to be an asshole."
Thank you for my best coffee-through-the-nostrils laugh of the year.
Isn't Gingrich so bizarre that it is easy to belittle him irrespective of where one is on the political spectrum?
Latest in Fresh Loaf
-
Family affair: Victims in spa murder-suicide were all related
Brother shoots his two sisters, their husbands, then himself
-
Rep. Stephanie Stuckey Benfield won't seek re-election, will lead eco-legal firm 2
Starts at GreenLaw after legislative session
-
First Slice 2/22/12: Five shot dead at Bu-Hi spa
Plus what the Girl Scouts are REALLY up to, and bring your umbrella ... or lock yourself in the storm cellar with a rosary and just pray
- More »
Author Archives
-
How to spot legislators in the wild 3
License plates, name tags, and pamphlets
-
"Occupiers" or others looking to crash Wild Hog Supper? 10
Wild Hog Dinner could be Occupied
- More »
