How City Hall reacted on the day that Braves announced move to Cobb (Full transcript!)
Goodbye Atlanta Braves, hello Smyrna Shitholes?
- Joeff Davis/CL File
- Goodbye Atlanta Braves, hello Smyrna Shitholes!?
When the Atlanta Braves announced on Nov. 11 that they planned to leave Turner Field and move to a proposed ballpark in Cobb County, metro Atlantans weren't the only people caught off guard. Judging from more than 600 emails released to the media yesterday afternoon by Mayor Kasim Reed's office, executive office staffers were also surprised.
In the hours after the unexpected announcement, the mayor's communications team and policy advisers scrambled to put together a response. Those internal conversations included deciding how to highlight the decision's potential impacts on surrounding neighborhoods while making clear distinctions between the Braves and Atlanta Falcons stadium deals. Language in some of the emails would later lead to the suspension of Deputy Chief Operating Officer Hans Utz. In one message, he doubted that the Braves would refer to themselves as the "Smyrna Shitholes" and wrote a haiku about the "Cobb Crackers" leaving the city. (Utz, in a statement released last night, apologized for the remarks. That statement can be found in full below.) The following day, Reed addressed the media about the Braves' move and plans to raze Turner Field.
It all began at 9:03 a.m.
From: Carlos Campos (Interim Director of Communications)
To: Duriya Farooqui (Chief Operating Officer), Hans Utz (Deputy Chief Operating Officer), Anne Torres (Deputy Director of Communications), Melissa Mullinax (Deputy Director of Communications)
Time: 9:03 a.m.
Subject: Braves moving to Cobb County? ?
My phone and email are blowing up about a report in today's Marietta Daily Journal claiming Braves plan to move to Cobb County. We are being asked for comment. Anyone? I'm clueless.
?
From: Anne Torres
To: Carlos Campos, Duriya Farooqui, Hans Utz, Melissa Mullinax
Time: 9:54 a.m.
Subject: Re: Braves moving to Cobb County?
Story is online: [[http://m.ajc.com/news/sports/baseball/braves-plan-to-build-new-stadium-in-cobb/nbpNQ/ |Links to AJC story]]
From: Duriya Farooqui
To: Anne Torres, Carlos Campos, Hans Utz, Melissa Mullinax
Time: 10:23 a.m.
Subject: Re: Braves moving to Cobb County? ?
MKR ed. %22MKR%22 is City Hall-speak for %22Mayor Kasim Reed.%22 is engaged. Please monitor stories and push on timing for statement if we decide to send. Right now stories seem better without it...
From: Anne Torres
To: Carlos Campos, Duriya Farooqui, Hans Utz, Melissa Mullinax
Time:10:28 a.m.
Subject: Re: Braves moving to Cobb County? ?
Story has been updated with statement from President of Braves, who mentions that MKR was informed of the decision. We're getting beat up online, and this story is pretty significant. I don't see how we don't respond sooner than later.
From: Carlos Campos
To: Anne Torres
CC: Duriya Farooqui, Hans Utz, Melissa Mullinax
Time: 10:32 a.m.
Subject: Re: Braves moving to Cobb County? ?
The Mayor asked me to put together a statement for his review; I have done so, and he is reviewing it.
From: "Selby, Douglass" (Attorney for the Atlanta and Fulton County Recreational Authority)
To: Hans Utz
CC: Cathy Hampton (City Attorney), Violet Ricks (Atlanta and Fulton County Recreation Authority executive director)
Time: 10:39 a.m.
Subject: Press Inquiries - Recreation Authority - Turner Field
Hans and Candace - The Recreation Authority is getting press inquiries. I have recommended that Violet work with your Press Office before responding. Does that make sense? If so, can I put her in touch with someone? I don't know the person that replaced Sonji.
Doug
From: Melissa Mullinax
To: Carlos Campos
CC: Anne Torres, Duriya Farooqui, Hans Utz
Time: 11:03 a.m.
Subject: Re: Braves moving to Cobb County? ? ?
I just spoke with Wilma Sothern at Central Atlanta Progress. They are getting lots of press calls, but will wait to hear from us on the Mayor's statemnent before responding.
Duriya Farooqui is calling Central Atlanta Progress President AJ Robinson now.
Carlos, we need to reach out to Violet Ricks at the County. Wilma told me that she talked with her and the Atl-Fulton Co Rec Authority has a board meeting on Wednesday. They don't plan to comment until after that meeting. Do you want to call her or want me to?
From: Anne Torres
To: Melissa Mullinax, Carlos Campos
CC: Duriya Farooqui, Hans Utz
Time: 11:11 a.m.
Subject: Re: Braves moving to Cobb County? ?
Hi everyone- Please proof read this statement carefully.
This is the statement the Mayor would like to issue: The Atlanta Braves are my favorite baseball team and one of the best in America. I wish them well. We have been working very hard with the Braves for a long time, and at the end of the day, there was simply no way the team was going to stay in downtown Atlanta without city taxpayers spending hundreds of millions of dollars to make that happen. Given the needs facing our city and the impact of the stadium on our neighborhoods, that was something I, and many others were unwilling to do. So we have been planning for this announcement and have already spoken to multiple organizations who are interested in redeveloping the entire Turner Field corridor. Over the next three years, we will be working with out prospective partners to bring residential and business development that is worthy of city and strengthens our downtown. Those conversations will continue and I am excited about how we use the land that is now Turner Field, to be a tremendous asset for our residents, or city, and our region for years to come.
From: Carlos Campos
To: Anne Torres
CC: Melissa Mullinax, Duriya Farooqui, Hans Utz
Time: 11:19 a.m.
Subject: Re: Braves moving to Cobb County? ?
There are typos.
Need a command after "I, and many others ..."
Need "our" in front of "city" where it says 'worthy of city."
Need to fix "or city" in last sentence to say "our city."
From: Anne Torres
To: Carlos Campos
CC: Melissa Mullinax, Duriya Farooqui, Hans Utz
Time: 11:20 a.m.
Subject: Re: Braves moving to Cobb County?
Thanks Carlos. Does anyone have any other edits?
From: Melissa Mullinax
To: Anne Torres
CC: Carlos Campos, Duriya Farooqui, Hans Utz
Time: 11:26 a.m.
Subject: Re: Braves moving to Cobb County?
?
Typo in "over next 3 years" sentence - change out to our.
From: Duriya Farooqui
To: Anne Torres, Melissa Mullinax, Carlos Campos
CC: Hans Utz
Time: 11:27 a.m.
Subject: Re: Braves moving to Cobb County?
I would be specific about impact of Turner field (not just stadium) on neighborhood given lack of transit. We need to protective about arguments we made for Falcons.
From: Carlos Campos
To: Duriya Farooqui, Hans Utz, Melissa Mullinax, Anne Torres
Time: 11:34 a.m.
Subject: Questions on Braves
This announcement was a complete surprise to me. Wish I had known and I wouldn't be on my heels, communications-wise. Having said that, here are questions Mayor will get next time he is seen in public. I think we need answers so we can create talking points for mayor. These are just a handful of questions i can think of on the fly ... Oh, and Mayor already has an interview with Scott Slade scheduled for WSB Radio at 10 am that had been set prior to this. so ... we need to be ready...
1. How long has the city/Mayor Reed known the Braves were moving?
2. Did you withhold this news until after election?
3. What did the city offer the Braves to stay?
4. Did the Braves know Cobb County's offer of $450 million?
5. Is the city still trying to keep Braves, or is this a done deal?
6. How bad of a blow is this to the city?
7. Why was the city so willing to put up $200 million in taxpayer money to keep the Falcons, but seemingly allowing the Braves to walk?
8. How would you characterize the negotiations with the Braves? Contientious? Friendly?
Again - just a few thoughts I've dashed off...
open to any other questions and answers.
From: Duriya Farooqui
To: Anne Torres
Time: 12:19 p.m.
Subject:
Anne, can you please forward latest version. I just spoke to MKR.
From: Anne Torres
To: Duriya Farooqui
Time: 12:23 p.m.
Subject: Re:
Yes, just got home.
Here it is:
The Atlanta Braves are one of the best baseball teams in America, and I wish them well. We have been working very hard with the Braves for a long time, and at the end of the day, there was simply no way the team was going to stay in downtown Atlanta without city taxpayers spending hundreds of millions of dollars to make that happen. It is my understanding that our neighbor, Cobb County, made a strong offer of of $450M in public support to the Braves and we are simply unwilling to match that with taxpayer dollars. Given the needs facing our city and the impact of Turner Field stadium on surrounding neighborhoods, that was something I, and many others were unwilling to do. We have been planning for the possibility of this announcement and have already spoken to multiple organizations who are interested in redeveloping the entire Turner Field corridor. Over the next three years, we will be working with our prospective partners to bring residential and business development that is worthy of our city and strengthens our downtown. Those conversations will continue and I am excited about how we use the land that is now Turner Field, to be a tremendous asset for our residents, our city, and our region for years to come.
From: Duriya Farooqui
To: A.J. Robinson (Central Atlanta Progress president)
Time: 12:28 p.m.
Subject: Fw:
Draft .. being tweaked. Attaches above statement
From: Anne Torres
To: Duriya Farooqui, Carlos Campos, Melissa Mullinax, Hans Utz
CC: Candace Byrd, Michael Sterling, Katrina Taylor-Parks
Time: 12:30 p.m.
Subject: Final Statement on Atlanta Braves
Hi everyone-
Below is the Mayor's statement on the Atlanta Braves. Please note that the Mayor would like to hold a press avail tomorrow am at 10:30 to answer questions about the move.
The Atlanta Braves are one of the best baseball teams in America, and I wish them well. We have been working very hard with the Braves for a long time, and at the end of the day, there was simply no way the team was going to stay in downtown Atlanta without city taxpayers spending hundreds of millions of dollars to make that happen. It is my understanding that our neighbor, Cobb County, made a strong offer of of $450M in public support to the Braves and we are simply unwilling to match that with taxpayer dollars. Given the needs facing our city and the impact of Turner Field stadium on surrounding neighborhoods, that was something I, and many others were unwilling to do. We have been planning for the possibility of this announcement and have already spoken to multiple organizations who are interested in redeveloping the entire Turner Field corridor. Over the next three years, we will be working with our prospective partners to bring residential and business development that is worthy of our city and strengthens our downtown. Those conversations will continue and I am excited about how we use the land that is now Turner Field, to be a tremendous asset for our residents, our city, and our region for years to come.
Thanks,
Anne
From: Duriya Farooqui
To: Anne Torres
Time: 12:32 p.m.
Subject: Re: Final Statement on Atlanta Braves
He said he would put in 'neighborhoods that lack transit'. Please confirm if he wants to leave it out.
From: Duriya Farooqui
To: Anne Torres
Time: 12:33 p.m.
Subject: Re: Final Statement on Atlanta Braves
Or neighborhoods without transit access...
From: Anne Torres
To: Duriya Farooqui
Time: 12:36 p.m.
Subject: Re: Final Statement on Atlanta Braves
he said he changed his mind.
From: Hans Utz
To: Duriya Farooqui
CC: Anne Torres, Melissa Mullinax, Carlos Campos, Hans Utz
Time: 12:40 p.m.
Subject: Re: Braves moving to Cobb County?
To Duriya's point, should we reference "hundreds of millions of unauthorized tax dollars" or some other clear delineation between what happened with Falcons versus what would have been needed for the Braves? The hotel motel tax was already authorized by the State, did not impact residents, and could not be used for any other purpose than Falcon Stadium. None of those points are true for monies possibly spent on Turner Field... Sent from my iPad
From: Hans Utz
To: Anne Torres
CC: Duriya Farooqui, Carlos Campos, Melissa Mullinax, Hans Utz, Candace Byrd, Michael Sterling, Katrina Taylor-Parks
Time: 12:42 p.m.
Subject: Re: Final Statement on Atlanta Braves
Omelettes out of cracked eggs. It's a good, strong statement.
Sent from my iPad
From: Duriya Farooqui
To: Hans Utz
Time: 12:43 p.m.
Subject: Re: Final Statement on Atlanta Braves
Thanks. We have been at it all morning.
From: webmaster at atlantaga.gov
To: sajacobs at atlantaga.gov
Time: 12:44 p.m.
Subject: City of Atlanta, GA: Statement from Mayor Kasim Reed on the Atlanta Braves
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: 11/11/2013
Media Statement
Statement from Mayor Kasim Reed on the Atlanta Braves
ATLANTA - The Atlanta Braves are one of the best baseball teams in America, and I wish them well. We have been working very hard with the Braves for a long time, and at the end of the day, there was simply no way the team was going to stay in downtown Atlanta without city taxpayers spending hundreds of millions of dollars to make that happen. It is my understanding that our neighbor, Cobb County, made a strong offer of of $450M in public support to the Braves and we are simply unwilling to match that with taxpayer dollars. Given the needs facing our city and the impact of Turner Field stadium on surrounding neighborhoods, that was something I, and many others were unwilling to do. We have been planning for the possibility of this announcement and have already spoken to multiple organizations who are interested in redeveloping the entire Turner Field corridor. Over the next three years, we will be working with our prospective partners to bring residential and business development that is worthy of our city and strengthens our downtown. Those conversations will continue and I am excited about how we use the land that is now Turner Field, to be a tremendous asset for our residents, our city, and our region for years to come.
From: Brian McGown (President/CEO of Invest Atlanta)
To: Carlos Campos, Melissa Mullinax
Time: 1:54 p.m.
Subject: Fwd: Final Statement on Atlanta Braves
We would like to respond to press inquiries with a statement... Here's a draft.
Let us know what you think... USA Today also called for an interview. We are NOT doing any interviews at this point.
The revitalization of the neighborhoods adjacent to Turner Field has been and remains a top priority for Invest Atlanta. Last year, we issued a Request for Ideas (RFI) focused on the redevelopment of the 55 acres of surface parking lots around the stadium. The level of interest received from several of the country's top mixed-use development firms is a testament to the viability of revitalizing the area. The property's prime location adjacent to the heart of downtown makes it ripe for development, regardless of whether the Braves play there 81 out of 365 days a year.
Along with Mayor Kasim Reed, who chairs our board, Invest Atlanta was reviewing and vetting the RFI responses and preparing an RFP for redevelopment around Turner Field. Although the Braves' announcement of plans to move to suburban Cobb County will impact what happens, it in no way diminishes Invest Atlanta's commitment to help guide the redevelopment of Peoplestown, Summerhill and other historic neighborhoods. Through innovative financing tools including Emerging Markets Tax Credits and Tax Allocation District funds, Invest Atlanta and the City of Atlanta are in a good position to shepherd the process and encourage community involvement.
Looking forward, Mayor Reed said it best, "Over the next three years, we will be working with our prospective partners to bring residential and business development that is worthy of our city and strengthens our downtown. Those conversations will continue and I am excited about how we use the land that is now Turner Field, to be a tremendous asset for our residents, our city, and our region for years to come."
From: Melissa Mullinax
To: Brian McGowan
CC: Carlos Campos, Duriya Farooqui, Anne Torres
Time: 3:01 p.m.
Subject: Re: Final Statement on Atlanta Braves
I think it's great, but I expect Carlos will need the Mayor to sign off before you can issue. Carlos?
From: Stephanie Johnson-Hardy (Council President Ceasar Mitchell's chief of staff)
To: Katrina Taylor-Parks (Reed's deputy chief of staff), Duriya Farooqui, Hans Utz, Carlos Campos, Anne Torres, Melissa Mullinax
CC: City Council Members (all), Dexter Chambers, Rhonda Dauphin Johnson (Atlanta City Council clerk), Candace Byrd, Cathy Hampton, Tangela Williams, Stephanie Johnson-Hardy, Jim Elgar
Time: 3:44 p.m.
Subject: Request
Katrina,
Per our earlier conversation, Council President Mitchell is requesting Mayor Reed to provide a briefing tomorrow with all members of Council on the Braves stadium relocation. As it appears, the members of Council collectively were not privy to this information prior to it being broadcast on the news.
Please contact me back as soon as possible with a potential timeframe so that we can work in concert to get this done.
Thanks.
From: Katrina Taylor-Parks
To: Stephanie Johnson-Hardy, Duriya Farooqui, Hans Utz, Carlos Campos, Anne Torres, Melissa Mullinax
CC: City Council Members (all), Dexter Chambers, Rhonda Dauphin Johnson, Candace Byrd, Cathy Hampton, Tangela Williams, Stephanie Johnson-Hardy, Jim Elgar
Time: 3:54 p.m.
Subject: Re: Request
Thank you Stefanie for the follow up email. As stated in our conversation, I will respond to the request as quickly as possible. Also as discussed, Council may be receiving calls today from the Administration in an effort to discuss the media reports today.
Thanks,
Katrina
From: Hans Utz
To: Carlos Campos, Duriya Farooqui, Melissa Mullinax
Time: 4:25 p.m.
Subject: RE: FYI
Calling now to correct mistakes
From: Brian McGowan
To: Melissa Mullinax
CC: Carlos Campos, Duriya Farooqui, Anne Torres
Time: 4:30 p.m.
Subject:
Carlos?
From: Carlos Campos
To: Melissa Mullinax
CC: Brian McGowan, Duriya Farooqui, Anne Torres
Time: 4:42 p.m.
Subject: Re: Final Statement on Atlanta Braves
Per MKR - stand down on any public reaction or comments. Thank you.
From: Brian McGowan
To: Carlos Campos
CC: Melissa Mullinax, Duriya Farooqui, Anne Torres
Time: 4:45 p.m.
Subject: Re: Final Statement on Atlanta Braves
Got it. Exactly what we've been doing. Thank you.
From: A.J. Robinson
To: Sonji Jacobs Dade (Reed's former communications director)
Time: 4:58 p.m.
Subject: CAP Statement on the Atlanta Braves
Greetings CAP Stakeholders,
Central Atlanta Progress and its leadership are, of course, disappointed about the Atlanta Braves' intention to move to Cobb County. We strongly believe that the team belongs in the city of Atlanta and we are hopeful that the Braves and the City will develop a scenario that will keep them at Turner Field far beyond 2016.
The Braves have been an important part of the urban fabric of Atlanta for almost 50 years. With the incredible change that is taking shape in the central city, we would like to see the Atlanta Braves continue to be a key part of the positive momentum.
A statement from Atlanta Mayor Kasim Reed can also be found here.
Best regards,
A.J. Robinson
From: Campos, Carlos A.
To: Mullinax, Melissa
CC: McGowan, Brian, Farooqui, Duriya, Eloisa Klementich, Torres, Anne
Date: Mon, 11 Nov 2013 16:42:41 -0500
Subject: Re: Final Statement on Atlanta Braves
Per MKR - stand down on any public reaction or comments. Thank you.
From: Carlos Campos
To: Hans Utz
Time: 7:19 p.m.
Subject: Q&A
Hans, I took a stab at these based on our conversations. I want to provide to Mayor in prep for tomorrow morning's presser? Would you review my responses, please?
1. How long has the city/Mayor Reed known the Braves were moving?
The city has been in discussions with the Braves for the past 18 months, in anticipation of their lease nearing an end at Turner Field. We first learned of their plans to move to Cobb County last Thursday afternoon.
2. Did you withhold this news until after election?
Absolutely not; we first learned about their plans to relocate to Cobb County last Thursday.
3. What did the city offer the Braves to stay?
The city never truly got an opportunity to counter an offer by another jurisdiction. The Braves provided us a detailed proposal in September of their needs and the city was in the process of evaluating this proposal and conducting due diligence when the Braves approached us to tell us they were moving to Cobb.
4. Did the Braves know Cobb County's offer of $450 million?
We did not know of this offer until last Thursday.
5. Is the city still trying to keep Braves, or is this a done deal?
We certainly are hopeful the Braves are still open to staying in Atlanta. However, any discussion will be had in the context of making sure taxpayers are not saddled with public debt for years to come.
6. How bad of a blow is this to the city?
Certainly, we want to keep the Braves in the city. But any notion that this is an indication of the city's overall economic health is simply incorrect. I submit that the Braves are actually bucking a trend. During the Reed administration, Coca-Cola, AT&T, AthenaHealth, Porsche Cars North America and Pulte Homes have all either relocated or moved jobs into the city.
7. Why was the city so willing to put up $200 million in taxpayer money to keep the Falcons, but seemingly allowing the Braves to walk?
The two are completely different situations. The city is using hotel/motel tax revenue to fund a $200 million portion of the Falcons stadium. The hotel/motel tax is generated by the millions of visitors who come to our city every year. The hotel/motel tax was specifically designated (by law) for the construction of a new stadium. There is no similar revenue stream dedicated to the Braves. Any public money for the Braves would need to be identified and would likely be taken from infrastructure improvements planned for the city - bridges, roads, intersections, traffic light synchronizations.
8. How would you characterize the negotiations with the Braves? Contientious? Friendly?
The city has neogtiated with the Atlanta Braves in good faith and in the best interest of our city's financial responsibility. We believe we have treated them with respect and have bent over backwards to understand their needs.
From: Hans Utz
To: Carlos Campos
Time: 7:20 p.m.
Subject: Re: Q&A
Hans Utz, 7:20 p.m. (to Carlos Campos): Will do eating with my kids can I get to it in 40?
From: Carlos Campos
To: Hans Utz
Time: 7:24 p.m.
Subject: Re: Q&A
Of course! Please take a look at the remarks i sent earlier as well. Thanks much.
From: Stephanie Johnson-Hardy
To: Katrina Taylor-Parks
CC: Duriya Farooqui, Hans Utz, Carlos Campos, Anne Torres, Melissa Mullinax, Dexter Chambers, Rhonda Dauphin Johnson, Candace Byrd, Cathy Hampton, Tangela Williams, Jim Elgar
Time: 8:46 p.m.
Subject: Re: Request
Checking in. Where are we on getting the briefing scheduled?
From: Hans Utz
To: Duriya Farooqui, Carlos Campos
Time: 9:25 p.m.
Subject: Fwd: Link from Twitter
FYI. Thoughts? Sent from my iPad [Links to AJC story].
From: Hans Utz
To: Carlos Campos
CC: Hans Utz, Duriya Farooqui
Time: 9:50 p.m.
Subject: Re: Q&A
My thoughts:
- 6: they are still the Atlanta Braves. They are not going to call themselves the Cobb Crackers, or the Smyrna Shitholes. They will still be the Atlanta Braves, and that is an indication of the value of the city.
- 7: Hotel motel tax is designated by STATE law, which I think is an important distinction. We do not control the levers to change it.
That is all. Though I do like the ring of the Smyrna shitholes.
From: Carlos Campos
To: Hans Utz
CC: Duriya Farooqui
Time: 9:52 p.m.
Subject: Re: Q&A
Er, I will edit appropriately.
Thanks for your help today.
From: Hans Utz
To: Carlos Campos
CC: Hans Utz, Duriya Farooqui
Time: 10:03 p.m.
Subject: Re: Q&A
Are you saying that you will not allow me to say 'Smyrna Shitholes' on national TV? Cause I am all geared up for it. I might actually compose a poem or some form of haiku to express my thoughts:
The Braves might leave us
Becoming the Cobb Crackers
I feel bad for them
There's more where that came from. Sadly.
In a statement released last night along with the emails, Utz said:
Those emails reflect a lapse in judgment on my part, for which I sincerely apologize and truly regret. I was the lead negotiator attempting to keep the Braves at Turner Field; an ongoing process of 18 months. The emails were sent at the end of a long, and frustrating, day in which the Atlanta Braves had announced their intentions to leave the City of Atlanta. The emails were my ill-advised attempt at using humor to make a point about the Braves still being a part of the greater metropolitan region. They were not meant to disparage our suburban neighbors. I recognize the remarks were inappropriate and simply should not have been made and I have been reprimanded for them.