In Episode 2 of "Top Chef": Las Vegas, there were a few obvious, spirited political issues included in the plot. One was whether or not a girls versus boys challenge is sexist. And of course the legalization of gay marriage.
Youll all be glad that Im not going to discuss those issues in this column. OK, well, for the record, I think people should be able to wed whomever they want.
But, what I felt was the biggest controversy of the episode was the comment made that the boys food was contrived and that mass appeal is as important as the judges opinion.
These are both issues I take pretty seriously. The former is an issue we battle every day in my kitchens.
Ill be honest, Im fed up with the whole simple, easy, casual food camp, versus the, conceptual, creative, plated food opponent. Its a silly debate. And Im willing to bet that anyone who says, I just cook simple food and plate it simply, is defending their lack of artistry or their experience in conceptualizing dishes. Its an excuse.
If contrived equals beautifully presented, tight and tasty food, Im on team contrived.
Its like the Notorious B.I.G. versus Tupac feud within our industry. With, for the most part, the West coast playing the role of the simple, unpretentious dish, and the East coast the highly designed crowd. Id say that's accurate of the rap war as well. Biggy was more of the technical lyricist.
Regardless of your stance, the fact is, "Top Chef" is judged by highly-respected chefs and personalities, who, as they stated in the episode, have eaten thousands of versions of everything.
In order for a tuna tartar, a gazpacho or a chips and salsa to stand out, it has to be more than delicious. It must be thoughtful and inspired. It should also display artistic vision and speak to the soul of its creator.
I have no doubt that chicken wings and lamb chops, for instance, are delicious. But theyre common. And common equals average. Which equals middle of the road (at best) on "Top Chef".
And that inevitably takes us to the rationalization that the viewers heard in this episode. And that we hear every season. That, well... the guests enjoyed it. So take that Tom! Harrumph!
The guests should enjoy it, duh. Could you imagine a designer on a fashion competition show saying to a judge... well, the model said it was comfortable !?!
Old Navy wont win, place, or show you on "Top Chef".
It is this type of thinking that breeds mediocrity in our industry. That food only has to be good enough. Its the attitude that perpetuates the appearance of the ubiquitous chicken entree. The burger at a non-burger restaurant. Soup du jour. And even bread service. Really, think about it. Why bread to start the meal in 95% of fine dining restaurants? Do you start your meals at home with a selection of breads and butter?
Of course, in the real world of business there's a balance. And sometimes compromise is a grilled shrimp or crab cake. I dont suggest neighborhood chefs to all storm into their owners office and proclaim its me or the artichoke dip. But for Top Chef, I would suggest caring about presentation. And cooking for the judges.
I cant believe that Taqueria Los Hermanos isn't on this list. They have some of…
Following up on the PG/FSB thread: First, I'm a native Atlantan, and I loved Chef…
I'm really disappointed at Mr. Bostock's less than fair review of Lips Atlanta. It sounds…
Were there sliders?
Straight people be havin' kids and goin' to church. You seen this, you heard about…
RIP Hollywood HOTS...Backstreet...etc... This town used to swing...and strut...now it shuffles. A 24 hr. moveable…